Rating:
PG-13
House:
The Dark Arts
Characters:
Harry Potter
Genres:
Drama
Era:
Multiple Eras
Spoilers:
Philosopher's Stone Chamber of Secrets Prizoner of Azkaban Goblet of Fire Quidditch Through the Ages Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them
Stats:
Published: 04/28/2003
Updated: 04/28/2003
Words: 8,480
Chapters: 1
Hits: 2,894

Walking Shadow

Pogrebin

Story Summary:
‘There is a story here, just one thread in the knotted up wool ball of history, stretched out and twisted, curled around a finger like a noose. It is not truth, because it is words, and in the sin of writing down life, it changes.’ July 31st 2030: for the second time in his life, Harry Potter makes a choice. Truth. Words. Fate. Reality. Magic. And stories themselves. Stylistic metafiction.

Posted:
04/28/2003
Hits:
2,894
Author's Note:
For Christina Black, exceptional editor whose excellence I shall effusively edify you with. : ) Without her, the mesh of stories that Walking Shadow consisted of would never have been integrated into a whole. There would be no story without her thoughtful concrit.

*

WALKING SHADOW

*

"Life's but a walking shadow, a poor player
That struts and frets his hour upon the stage
And then is heard no more. It is a tale
Told by and idiot, full of sound and fury,
Signifying nothing."

-Shakespeare

*

PROLOGUE

*

"No man has come to true greatness who has not felt in some degree that his life belongs to his race, and that what God gives him, He gives him for mankind." Brooks

*

THOUSANDS MOURN DEATH OF BOY WHO LIVED

GRANGER IMPLICATED YET AGAIN

By Staff Reporter O. Quirke

1st August 2030. Hogwarts.

It was a grim, rainy Thursday afternoon when the body of Harry James Potter, also known as the Boy Who Lived, was laid to rest on Hogwarts grounds. The first wizard to be accorded the honour, a crypt with a memorial plaque was specially built on school property at the request of Headmistress Minerva McGonagall. "Harry regarded Hogwarts as his home," she said, elegant and poised despite her great grief, by way of explanation.

The funeral of this great wizard was attended by thousands of mourners from all over the nation, and indeed, the world. Seated in the front row, mute with shock and sadness, were the Headmistress, Deputy Headmaster Severus Snape and family of the deceased Ronald Weasley, including Unspeakable Virginia Weasley. Harry Potter's elusive ex-wife, the stunning Gabrielle Delacour, too, was seated beside them. This reporter caught up with her for a rare exchange to try to ascertain why such an acclaimed wizard, who was seen by many to have everything anyone could dream of, would do such a thing.

"It was Hermione Granger!" Ms. Delacour accused-- and which witch or wizard could forget that infamous name? The Ministry seems to agree, having shifted Miss Granger from low-security Trosinka prison to Azkaban this very morning.

What is the real truth behind those words? This Daily Prophet reporter pledges to find out the truth and bring it to light, because the Wizarding world deserves to know who stole such a renowned figure from our midst.

*

PART ONE: PAIN

(Azkaban, 2030)

*

"Words, as is well known, are the great foes of reality." Conrad

August 31st

I.

"Are you ready, Miss Granger?"

Hermione nodded, twisting the loose fabric of the plain grey prison robes with her fingers, staining them with melted chocolate. "Yes."

Orla Quirke retrieved a small, greyish device from the depths of her vinyl handbag. "Should I turn the Magicorder on? Or do you want a quill?"

"Today...today I want a quill." Her fingers reached out hungrily for the implement before she even finished her sentence.

The Daily Prophet reporter surrendered it grudgingly.

She felt like she was handing over a weapon.

( "the Quill is mightier than the sword," or so they said)

II.

I promised you a story with nothing but the truth, and here it is.

50 ¾ YEARS AGO:

A persistent spermatozoa ad a complacent egg fused together in an absurdly random chance that created life.

50 YEARS AGO:

Harry James Potter was born, with ten fingers and ten toes, weighing approximately six pounds.

49 YEARS AGO:

His smooth, clean baby forehead was marked with a lightning-shaped scar.

27 YEARS AGO:

He-

defeated Voldemort

betrayed one friend

and lost another.

26 YEARS AGO:

I was put in Trosinka Wizard Prison for crimes against the Wizarding Community.

20 YEARS AGO:

He captained the English national team to victory at the Quidditch World Cup.

Amid the festivities, Albus Dumbledore moved on to his next great adventure.

12 YEARS AGO:

He married Gabrielle Delacour.

11 ½ YEARS AGO:

He divorced Gabrielle Delacour.

7 YEARSAGO:

A Muggle man in a pale blue shirt stabbed him, but he miraculously survived.

Under Veritaserum, when asked why he had tried to murder a stranger on the street, he replied, 'I don't know.'

4 YEARS AGO:

He dropped five hundred feet from his broom and spent a week in a coma at St.Mungo's, but miraculously survived.

2 YEARS AGO:

He accidentally added hemlock instead of mint to his afternoon tea, but miraculously survived.

1 MONTH AGO:

He placed a wand to his head and, miraculously, killed himself.

It was his 50th Birthday, and I wrote him a letter.

After that, they moved me to Azkaban.

So it goes.

TODAY:

The Daily Prophet wants my story.

This is all the truth I know.

September 31st

"Words not only affect us temporarily; they change us." Riesman

I.

"Give me."

Orla Quirke handed the hot-pink quill to Hermione Granger, wrinkling her nose at the incongruity of such a vibrant object in prematurely wizened hands. She withdrew her hand from the table quickly, casting a nervous glance at the guard outside the door. "Are you-- all right? You look tired..." she trailed off.

Hermione ignored her, head bent and hand moving furiously.

Thirty-five years ago, seated in the Gryffindor common room, she might have been doing Arithmancy homework.

II.

For tragedy, we must have a hero with a FATAL FLAW that will cause his FALL, guided by the hand of FATE.

For tragedy we must have EMPATHY.

For tragedy--

For tragedy--

( no, I can tell the story. Just a little more chocolate, Miss Quirke- )

We must have LOVE and BETRAYAL, but above all, there must be DEATH. No, above all, there must be a story. That is what I want to tell you, that we are all characters in a story that is being told to children who do not care, because their disgusting innocence makes them disbelieve anything so real.

Words: there are endless sentences wrapping around our heads and slithering into our skins.

They distort what is real, and by capturing the truth in words it changes. So you read the words Harry Potter was eleven the first time he faced the wizard known as You-Know-Who... but there is nothing behind them.

Harry was locked in a closet every night for eleven years.

Harry never felt a warm hug before Hogwarts.

Harry was suddenly thrust into a world where

-everyone loved him

-everyone cared

-everyone wanted him

-everyone thought he was a hero.

Just words, you see, but underneath those words are words like 'ache,' 'loneliness,' 'pain,' 'bitterness,' 'acceptance,' 'desperation,' 'craving.'

We are shoved into the spaces between the lines.

I'm sorry, Harry, for all the words that made you a hero, for all the fates that conspired to bring you down (you were so far up, beyond anything we could even imagine, weren't you?)--

Oh, but it was lucky, too, wasn't it? No normal human being should catch Death's eye so many times.

"Flirted with Death," people say, and it's a strange saying. Are you wedded to life, Boy Who Lived? Then why keep cold Death as a paramour?

As I said, silly phrase.

You should have been sorted into Slytherin, Harry.

( back to my cell? But wait, I haven't finished-- there's more, I swear, just not back to my...oh God... Please? )

October 31st

"Words, like glass, obscure when they do not aid vision." Joubert

I.

"You're late, Miss Granger. Sit." Orla Quirke was surprised by the speed with which Hermione complied.

"There's a mild form of Imperius in the Sedative Spell," the guard who brought her in offered, chuckling at Orla's expression. "Nothing Dark. Just an extra safeguard. For your protection, you know, Miss Quirke..."

The reporter looked queasily at the blank look on Hermione's face. "She's worse than last month. Again. How am I supposed to get a story here?"

At the word 'story,' Hermione looked up. "My quill," she asked, her voice trembling slightly. "I-- want to--" for a moment, she sounded confounded by the expression itself. "I want."

She laughed a little too freely.

"Here," Orla placed the smooth feather into Hermione's outstretched fingers.

I.

Do you know about words?

My third grade teacher understood them; she could go on for hours. She kept me after school sometimes because she knew I liked to listen- I understood while other people didn't. People are like words.

There are the plain and simple verbs like Seamus, who just do and don't think, and adjectives like Lavender, who just stands at the edges and decorates, and the conjunctions like Ron, who joined us up, Harry. Of course, there are the more complicated ones like morphemes that can't be broken down any further; they are pared down and scrubbed raw versions of themselves, their pure forms without any excesses. And if you try and break them down any further, they become meaningless. After twenty-six years in walls, I'm a morpheme.

But I really want to talk about vocables to you, Harry. They're words, but you take them just as a group of sounds and letters and pieces, and you don't think about what they mean. Just a mixture of things that you can say, that can come out of your mouth. And sometimes they can be so ingenious that you don't even realise that underneath the sounds and letters and pieces there's no meaning.

November 31st

"If we use words, there is a very grave danger they will be misinterpreted." Halderman

I.

There is a story here, just one thread in the knotted up wool ball of history, stretched out and twisted, curled around a finger like a noose. It is not all truth, for people can only say what they know, and that is never the truth.

It is not truth, because it is words, and in the sin of writing down life, it changes.

II.

The quill shuddered out of her grip and rolled off the table, landing on the hard floor with a metallic click. It rang in her ears, and she clapped her hands over them violently.

"Miss Granger!" Orla pushed her chair back abruptly, the legs making a screeching sound against the ground.

Hermione screamed.

The chair toppled, and Orla staggered backwards.

"Stop it!" Hermione yelled, pulling her legs up onto the chair. "Stop it, stop it, stop it! No more noise. No more!"

The door opened with a magical pop, and the guard brushed past Orla, barely sparing a glance to check whether she was all right. "Locomotor Mortis!" he cried-- for no apparent reason, Orla noted, as the prisoner wasn't exactly moving around.

Hermione's legs bound together, and she overbalanced in her chair, landing on the floor with a dull thump in a sobbing heap. "There's no truth..." she gasped out. "No truth but death and birth and suffering." She repeated absurdist schoolroom philosophy in a voice that was gravelly with exertion, twisting away from the guard.

"Impedimenta!" he cried, but she rolled away from it.

"In the middle of the hall, there is a comforting fire to warm the hall; outside, the storms of winter rain or snow are raging. The sparrow flies swiftly in through one door of the hall, and out through another."

A muffled gasp.

"While he is inside the hall, he is safe from the winter storms, but after a few moments of comfort, he--"

The wet sound of flesh against flesh.

"--vanishes from sight into the wintry world from which he came. Such is the life of man," she recited, each word raising her voice higher until she was shrieking.

A grunt of pain.

"They give birth astride a grave, the light gleams an instant, then it's night once more!"

Orla reached out and snatched the paper from the desk.

"Words!" Hermione reached out for the paper, her arms flailing against a muscular grip. A draught of Calming Concoction was shoved into her mouth; she choked on it but continued to speak. "The words, they change...paper! I need paper, oh God." Her tears ran into her mouth, tasting salty and dramatic. "I want my quill...I--want..."

"Somnus."

December 31st

"Words are, of course, the most powerful drug used by mankind." Rudyard Kipling

I.

The warden shoved a box into her hands with an uncomfortable look on his face, stark in the early morning light.

"Why-- surely there's someone else who'd want--?" Orla left the question uncompleted.

"No. Parents are dead, of course. And her friends-- well, she had none," he confirmed, crossing his arms. "Personal effects and...ramblings. I'm sure you'll weave something suitably sensationalist out of it."

"How did she-- exactly?"

He shrugged his shoulders delicately. "Exhaustion. Starvation. Blood loss, even--"

"Blood loss?"

"She wrote on paper she stole from your sessions, Miss Quirke, but used more easily available substitutes when she ran out." His expression darkened. "The sharpened edge of a spoon-handle serves as an excellent quill when pressed to flesh."

Orla blanched. "Do you have records of that writing, it--"

He didn't even let her finish, shaking his head disgustedly. "There are photographs of the cadaver in the box, Miss Quirke. You'll have to transcribe her scribblings from them yourself; I'm ever so sorry."

"T-thankyou."

"Happy New Year, Miss Quirke."

*

PART TWO: HUNGER

(July 31st 2030)

*

Owl Post

(H. Granger to H. Potter)

He's haunted by the memory of a lost paradise

In his youth or a dream, he can't be precise

He's chained forever to a world that's departed

It's not enough, it's not enough

I.

You too will fade, quietly, without sound.

History forgives none; she is an uncaring, cruel mistress who holds you in her palm for a while and then tosses you on the floor to be trampled. A million boots digging into your celebrated features. Skewered and forgotten, like all things, a return to the primordial nothingness from which we originated.

Do I offer cold comfort?

The Boy Who Lived

(morning)

I am an idiot walking a tightrope of fortune and fame

And though I'll never forget your face

Sometimes I can't remember my name

I.

Harry Potter tossed the letter into the fire.

It didn't burn.

He cursed under his breath. Trust Hermione to be able to manage Fireproofing Spell, even from the depths of Trosinka.

Forgotten?

His eyes roamed around his living room to the framed articles from the Daily Prophet that adorned the walls and the innumerable photographs of himself shaking hands with Ministry officials and celebrities, linking arms with pretty, smiling girls.

Don't you cry

Baby, please don't cry

I won't need your picture

Until we say goodbye

He waved from each one of them, his own smile too wide and eager. He closed his eyes and could almost hear the cheering in his ears, muted by adrenaline and then unbearably loud when he caught his breath.

For him.

You're wrong, Hermione.

A small part of him, unconvinced by the glossy paper reminders and shining medals and trophies he had won, (even the picture of him, sweaty and satisfied, raising the Quidditch Cup over his head in 2010) asked questions in the back of his mind.

Would it not be better to be forgotten?

No, that could never be. To give up all of this, all of the winking, laughing, smiling pictures that surrounded him like mirrors that reflected only the most beautiful moments of life. For what? To feel less guilt--

Less guilt for what?

For doing what he had to do?

He had been chosen (by fate?) to fight Voldemort (rid the world of evil?).

He was chosen.

(Where did destiny end and Harry Potter begin?)

God damn you, Hermione.

The pictures still waved, caught in their moment of splendour, and Harry Potter, surrounded by images of himself, suddenly felt very alone.

He swept away the photo frames of his later conquests from the table and stood up to search for those taken when he was younger, more inexperienced, just a boy...

The blurred snapshot covertly taken on Platform 9¾ as he stepped onto the train to begin his first year at Hogwarts, where he looked faintly ill and bewildered (and smiling at the edge, Lavender Brown, who died in the riots). Gilderoy Lockhart with his arm draped around him, where he looked uncomfortable and annoyed (and behind the lens, Colin Creevey, who was killed by Aurors). The photograph of himself with the other Triwizard Champions--

He pulled that picture down, not wanting to look at the beginnings of that smile on his lips, that look on his face which was molded by a thousand hands. They loved him, they lapped him up like cream, and why not, when he learned how to be everything they ever desired just so that they wouldn't ever leave him alone again? They wanted fate on their side, and he let himself be caught up in it.

On 18th Augut 2005, he had given his first interview; he had learned so well what they wanted, so well that on good days their desires almost meshed with his own, until he couldn't tell Harry Potter apart from the Boy Who Lived.

They were all gone, all those who knew Harry Potter: Ron, Hermione, Molly, even Petunia and Vernon and Dudley.

And Dumbledore had made him the Boy Who Lived, of course.

It was simply the continuation of a pre-planned act in which his role was already defined, and he turned out such a splendid performance, they even asked for encores.

II.

He can remember:

He was breathless and excited, thinking of front pages and bylines that ran "a boy like no other" and "saviour of the wizarding world," words that made him a hero. That catch in his breath when he saw his name printed out in words that seemed to ground his fairy tale existence. How could anything that existed in ink and paper be anything but absolutely real, even in the Wizarding world?

"Oh no, Miss Skeeter, I'd be most happy to meet with you at your convenience. Why don't you come down to my summer house this weekend? An exclusive interview. The truth and nothing else-- there's no need even for a Quick-Quotes Quill."

"A photo shoot? Such a marvelous idea."

"Of course, Miss Skeeter, I'd be happy to answer that question. Well...ever since I can remember, I've wished there was something more to life, locked in the cupboard under the stairs where the Dursleys--"

Magic

(afternoon)

The sweet smell of a great sorrow lies over the land

Plumes of smoke rise and merge into the leaden sky:

A man lies and dreams of green fields and rivers,

But awakes to a morning with no reason for waking

I.

(Myths which are believed in tend to come true)

Some days, he used to take a step back and wonder at the absurdity of it all.

That the Wizarding world was hinged on his exploits, that a poor orphan boy from nowhere could save the world eight times before his twentieth birthday and destroy evil in it's purest form (but was that really true?) before his twenty-third.

Rags to riches.

( "God, Harry," Gabrielle Delacour had chirped, latched onto his arm as they walked into his mansion in Spain. "This is so fictional!"

And maybe that's why he had married her. He had thought she understood. But she saw nothing and maybe the sign-on-the-dotted-line divorce meant that he didn't want to make her see.

in the kingdom of the blind...)

But wasn't that part of the Story?

Fairy tales only work with poor little oppressed orphans and evil relatives.

On bad days, he asked himself whether his father died because of the story, whether his mother sacrificed herself so that he could be a saviour, whether Dumbledore never saved the Wizarding world because he was the most practical hero, unlike a scrawny little boy with a scar on his forehead, whether the Dursleys tortured him because that was their role, just as he faced death and dealt it, because that was his...

In true fairy tales, they never ask themselves such questions.

II.

Cinderella steps out of her pumpkin carriage; her dress is white with silver spangled stars. Her hair is a well-washed, chestnut brown, arranged in perfect, angelic curls around a scrubbed, lily-white face.

Twenty minutes ago, she was dirty and lonely, an orphan with an evil stepfamily, and now she has two footmen, a carriage, and a gown. Her fairy godmother just waved a wand. How? She hadn't asked the question out loud, her mouth too caught up with spilled, inarticulate thankyous and oh lords and I can't believe its.

Magic, the pleasant-faced old woman said, with an all-knowing wink.

It was an idea too entrancing to be refuted. She nodded and exclaimed, instead, over the glass slippers that were conjured out of thin air for her servant's feet.

It is with these clumsy, ugly, oafish servant's feet that she plods by the doorman, but blinded by the dress and smile, he bows and lets her through. He wrinkles his nose without even realising it.

(Even magic can't erase the burned smell of cinders, nor can it give a girl culture, but it is enough)

Her fairy godmother appears behind her and whispers in her ear. Twelve O'clock.

Cinderella pales-- she had completely forgotten to ask when the dream ended. Did it really have to end?

Silly child, the old woman's face grows darker as she speaks. This is the way things are, the way they always were and will be. You mustn't fight against fate, because that's what has brought you this far.

Fate, godmother?

The story, she nodded. The beautiful young orphan, locked away by her jealous stepmother, must go to the ball. Must be happy. It's the way the story goes.

III.

He remembered the cool and slick feel of his wand in his hand as he swore on his life and magic itself to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth in a musty courtroom.

The rest of Hermione's trial was a blur, flashing before his eyes in still motion images and sound bytes (words, once again, that were in his mind, not in ink but memory).

Hermione saying,

"They have a right to know."

"Their sons and daughters are dying."

"They are human beings."

And the longest memory,

"How can you just Obliviate them so that their loved ones never existed? You're playing God, removing people from history itself, rewriting it like a cheap novel. Plucking people out of time itself. What gives you the right to take away an entire existence? It's worse than murder-- those Muggles that died in this war don't exist, have never existed, and will never exist, thanks to one flick of your wand. It's more cruel than anything Voldemort ever did."

She was wrong, of course, all wrong. It was for their own protection, and for the safeguarding of the Wizarding world. It was wrong to reveal its existence to them as she had done so self-righteously--

Hadn't she understood that when the Muggles had risen up in riots?

Blood and destruction, that was all the Muggles were capable of.

The prosecutor proving it,

"Your parents died in crossfire between Aurors and Death Eaters, didn't they, Miss Granger?"

(Emotional. Irrational.)

"You yourself are Muggle-born, aren't you, Miss Granger?"

(Not one of us.)

"Your sympathies would naturally lie with them, wouldn't they, Miss Granger?"

(Traitor.)

Yes, that was it. She was overreacting. They were right.

(Dumbledore would have never let it happen if it was wrong-- the headmaster had explained everything, and he had understood. She had made a mistake, and it had cost thousands their lives.)

A crossroads had been reached, a clear definition of 'us' and 'them,' unsavoury but unavoidable. He had made his choice for the world that belonged to him (he belonged to?), and she had made hers. She had chosen an 'us,' too, but he had found out that her 'us' was different from his.

(he decided not to remember the wave of reprisal killings against Mudbloods, the laws against cruelty to Muggles that were repealed, or the accusing expression on Hermione's face when he agreed that she had always had Muggle sentiments)

He was the champion of the Wizarding world.

His colour was the purest of lily-whites.

IV.

In this story, her destiny is different. Cinderella dances, her ball-gown floating like a dream around her, and when she runs to her pumpkin carriage as the clock strikes twelve, she leaves behind a beautiful shoe that fits an ugly foot.

And for ten days and ten nights, the lovestruck Prince and his men roam the country. He refuses to marry any of the other eligible maidens who are paraded for his perusal. He holds the shoe to his body so tightly that the heel breaks off and stabs him in the hand. The blood makes the glass shoe a bright, thin scarlet, like the "ruby slippers"--

Click your heels three times

Then you can go home.

But before that, let us not neglect to mention, you have to kill the witch, Dorothy.

It is so easy to perform murder on the wicked.

His attendant wipes off the blood; a little water clears them of the crime.

Finally, they come to the last house in the country, and in the back room, hunched over a stove, is Cinderella. The Prince approaches her warily. Without the gown, hair, and carriage, she is just another plain, young girl with a slightly hooked nose. She smells burned.

No, you're not the one from the Ball, he says regretfully, shaking his head. You're so plain and dirty.

She blushes and stammers and looks down. Her stepsisters smile. I'm sorry, sire.

And you speak like a servant, he continues dreamily. You're as common as muck; you're so different from her.

A tear rolls down Cinderella's cheek.

She hears the old woman in her ear whispering fate over and over again, and she stops crying.

Please, she begs. Please just let me try on the shoe?

The Prince sighs and shrugs.

She hikes her ragged skirt and proffers the servant's leg.

The shoe fits, of course.

(The old woman smiles, and her smile is like an incision.)

And suddenly Cinderella is in a ballroom seated beside the King and Queen.

Where am I? she asks.

The Queen looks concerned. In the ballroom of our palace, my darling. It's your sixteenth birthday, don't you remember? You have to pick a husband. All the eligible men of the kingdom have assembled.

Cinderella stands up, and the orchestra stops playing. There is an unnatural weight on her head, and with a start, she realises it is a crown. And the Prince?

Prince? The King laughs. What Prince? You're our only daughter, my love; the only Prince is the one you shall choose tonight.

The doors of the ballroom fling open, and a man dressed in a white suit with silver spangles on the edges walks into the room (the Prince, she realises, with a start-- but now he is not the Prince). His hair is done in perfect, angelic curls, but underneath it all lingers the smell of burning cinders. He turns his bright eyes on hers, and for a moment, it seems like the Princess is going to ask him to dance.

In this story, she shakes her head and walks right past him, the beginnings of cruelty on her lips. I will have no Prince, Cinderella says, signaling for the orchestra to play on. I am the Princess, and I walk alone.

V.

( "On the first day of classes in 1997, Potter's belongings had been owled to Dumbledore's office; there was no accompanying message or note, no clue as to what might have happened to the young wizard. Concerned that bodily harm had befallen Potter, the Headmaster had sent Black and Lupin out to investigate. In a few days' time, they returned with Harry in tow--a frightened, struggling boy, who appeared to not know his own Godfather, who seemed unable to recognize any of the castle's surroundings.

It was not a pleasant sight. Potter had to be physically restrained by Black and Lupin, locked between their arms, while alternately screaming and sobbing, his face red and tear-streaked. He had been dirty and smelly, his glasses gone, his body trembling. The most disquieting thing, however, had been the boy's refusal to open his eyes; whenever he did squint one open, he let out a fresh yelp, as if the sight of their concerned faces was the very thing driving him mad.

"What's been done to him?" Black had demanded, looking quite ill. Dumbledore ignored Black and instead spoke to Potter, saying his name--Harry?...Harry?--over and over again, as if trying to penetrate the terror the boy was fully engulfed in.

"I don't know," Dumbledore finally admitted, only after touching the boy's fiery brow once then immediately pulling back, as if he'd just received a burn. "But it would appear that...nothing's been done to him."

"How can you say that?" Black had cried, outraged...

After much argument about how to next proceed, Dumbledore finally hushed them all with a single glance. He pulled the traumatised boy aside, and out of earshot, spoke very softly with him for several long minutes. None of them could be sure what was being said, but it seemed as if Potter answered his headmaster at least once, and after doing so, Dumbledore let him be, returning to them with a grim expression upon his ancient face.

That one expression had said it all; Snape knew at once, without asking, that Harry Potter's looking-glass persona had finally been shattered. He didn't know how, or what had happened, but the boy must have found reason to look within himself...and had retreated fully when he saw that there was nothing looking back at him." )

That is one story.

In this story, Harry Potter nodded as Albus Dumbledore placed a hand on his shoulder, cast a quick Sober-Up Spell (the same sort they will use on Hermione in a month), and talked to him about glory and what is right.

'Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori,' he said, Petunia and Vernon Dursley having educated him at least that much.

Dumbledore shook his head, his blue eyes intense. "You won't die, Harry," he pronounced. "Don't you see? You're the Boy Who Lived. You can never leave this behind: it's become part of you now. The magic is part of you."

No, I'm part of the magic, he wanted to say, but didn't.

"This is your world, and you are its hero."

Harry nodded dumbly and even smiled a little before Dumbledore Obliviated him and sent him back to classes with a sherbet lemon and a story about missing the Hogwarts Express.

When Sirius looked at him, Dumbledore looked back gravely. "It is for the best," he said. "It must be."

VI.

The crown grows heavier on her head, pinching into her skin, and soon she bleeds. She fastens royal fingers around the gold band and tries to pull it off. She did not place the crown upon her head and so she cannot lift it either.

Hers are the consequences (not the act) to enjoy and endure.

Fate, my darling, her fairy godmother whispers into her ear at night when she whimpers.

In the morning, however, there is always a beautiful new dress and a pure white cloth, softer than baby's skin, to wipe her blood with, and the Princess believes she is happy.

*

PART THREE: FEAR

*

"If Dreams are like Memories..."

(evening)

And he talks to the river of lost love and dedication

And silent replies that swirl invitation

Flow dark and troubled to an oily sea

A grim intimation of what is to be

I.

( in my dreams I'm dying all the time )

There is a mountain in his dream, and he is standing at the bottom.

There is blood dripping from his lip and a gash above his right eye. His glasses lie in a twisted up, glittering heap behind him, abandoned to their fate. He holds his wand tightly, so tightly that his fingernails turn a chalky death-white.

There is a faint breeze, which pushes his sweaty hair from his face and allows a shining scar to be seen.

(the moment is picture-perfect, set in a grey-red Universe where Kubrick is God)

There is a black-haired young man with greenish eyes and a hardened expression standing at the pinnacle, his eyes locked with Harry's. His robes flutter ever so slightly, dispelling the illusion that he is just a statue.

"Tom Marvolo Riddle," Harry breathes, and his words solidify, forming scarlet letters in the air.

They float there like a ghostly personification of the alphabet before silently forming:

I AM LORD VOLDEMORT

The figure opens his mouth and laughs silently.

Harry takes a step closer, brittle ground crunching underneath his boots, and Tom Marvolo Riddle's skin whitens.

He takes another step:

( squish )

Tom Marvolo Riddle's eyes glow faintly red.

He takes another step:

( crunch )

Tom Marvolo Riddle's hair begins to fall in withered tufts.

He takes another step:

( squish )

Tom Marvolo Riddle's mouth is eaten away by the cold flesh of his face.

He takes another step:

( crunch )

Tom Marvolo Riddle's nose widens and flattens, slowly, like a bad shadow-fade effect in a Muggle film.

He takes another step:

( squish )

Tom Marvolo Riddle's body bends and then elongates, stretching skin like nylon over jagged bones that gleam moistly.

One more step and he will be at the top.

He lifts one leg and raises his wand and begins to mouth the words--

And Tom Marvolo Riddle does the same, raising his wand with a semi-smile and echoing the spell that Harry has begun to cast--

Avada Kedavra.

Harry's leg hits the ground:

Tom Marvolo Riddle turns into Voldemort.

Harry's eyes widen as the jet of green light hits him squarely in the chest, and he stumbles forward into the arms of his enemy only to find--

There is the cold, hard glass pressing between their embrace.

( Mirror, mirror, on the wall... )

Harry allows a hand that he knows is long and sinuous and whiter than a lily to drop his wand and gasps as he feels cold air enter through his slit-like nose.

His lifeless body hits the crumbling ground that is made of soil that was once people, and he wakes.

II.

There are other dreams, too.

The one where he sees his own name spelled out magically in the air, just like Voldemort's, and slowly four letters pull away from the rest and begin to glow, leaving his own name bereft and broken up...

H O

A R R Y J A M S P T T E

E R

A R R Y J A M S P T T E

And then the word 'hero' grows larger and larger, so big and so bright that he can't see his own name for its radiance.

Then there's the dream in which his mother's voice says 'destiny' over and over again, like she's calling out for a lover, and then she's real and beside him, all flesh and bone. She has a smell, like a perfume that Gabrielle used to wear (back in those days when he could bury his face in her hair and hold her too-soft hands and--).

"You killed me," she says, her lips thinning into a scowl. "You killed me, Harry Potter..." On the last syllable of his name, her face thins and stretches, her nose lengthening into avian hook. Her voice changes, hair lightens (red to silver). "You left me," Gabrielle Delacour says, her young eyes filmy with tears. "How could you leave me? You were supposed to save me."

Those words are like a cue, and a thousand ghostly forms rise up from the ground and stretch out their arms. "Save me," they cry, their phantom voices merging and coalescing.

Harry takes a step back, and another, as they press closer to him, and he is falling backwards...

Thump.

He lands on a chessboard, and the red queen bears down upon him with a murderous look in her eye. He stumbles back only to find that he is the white king, standing upright behind a line of pawns, knights, bishops, who all have their sabres drawn at the ready to defend him.

He cannot feel his own mouth as it opens and orders a line of pawns to go forward, and before he can gather his bearings, the board is a whirl of white attacking red and wood chips flying. To his left, a white bishop falls, but he can do nothing.

He is caught in the squares and in the motions that he is allowed to perform.

The rules bind him like ropes.

Soon, there are no more red pieces except for the queen. The bishop brings down his sword on her head, and her scream is pure, echoing forever in his ears, drowning out the 'no' that doesn't issue from his lips but just reverberates in his head.

As her crown falls to the ground, the red wood chips suddenly reform the pawns that were destroyed, and the white king mumbles a spell that casts the illusion that they were never broken in the first place.

III.

Though...

The worst nightmares are the ones that are real.

Harry remembered the feeling of standing in a circle twenty-seven years ago on this day (like he could forget it, even otherwise), arms linked with strangers and friends with the same intense feelings on their faces. Power flowed between them, so tangible that the air in the room was thick and glittery. Magic so old and great that it transcended wands and words and reached deep inside the wizard.

If he remembered everything, he would have to remember the sick feeling creeping up his spine, a chill that never quite dissipated. He knew what it felt like to be Tom Marvolo Riddle when he ripped his soul from its casing and vomited it into the pages of a diary.

But he is not in the business of accuracy, he is trying to assuage guilt, so he tries hard not to remember, and he succeeds (he's been practicing a long time).

"You call everything you can't understand Dark--" Ginny Weasley, well acquainted with darkness, had told him once.

If that was true, then this was Dark Magic at its worst, because he didn't understand it...

Or maybe he did?

(Double, double toil and trouble;
Fire burn and cauldron bubble.
)

Did he truly want to admit he knew the consequences of pressing the silver blade into his hands and drawing a circle of blood around them?

(Cool it with a baboon's blood,
Then the charm is firm and good.

But where are the warts? And where is Macbeth? But they too call to Hecate, like the witches in the play. Dressed in black, like Death Eaters)

Dean's eyes found Harry's for a moment, but he looked away just as quickly.

If Harry wanted to remember everything, he would remember the frightened look on Dean's Mudblood face, which was replaced by determination.

"She to whom vengeance belongeth, shew thyself!"

And after that, the strangest sense of having nothing within his body, of being able to float on his toes as magic flowed between them and from them. The pounding of blood in his ears, like maddened music, and the salty taste of lips and skin. Magic so old it called on nonexistent gods and was forged in flesh and blood and passion--

Just one word, whispered and screamed over and over, until his own throat was raw.

"Mnemosyne!"

Waking up in the morning, aching and older and pulling on robes, trying to avoid the other's faces, ironically wishing he could forget.

I woke up dead today

Had they imagined it would be easy to make a nation of Muggles forget? (And not everyone forgot; twenty years later a Muggle man in a pale blue shirt remembered, whether he knew it or not)

They had been very young then.

Search your memory

Create your history

Dean's shocked slack jaws as he sat on the floor in a heap of robes. "What have we done?" he had asked.

Harry can remember saying, "We have saved our world."

Though he doesn't remember thinking, "At what cost?"

The Alchemist

(afternoon)

His blood has frozen & curdled with fright

His knees have trembled & given way in the night

His hand has weakened at the moment of truth

His step has faltered

I.

Harry felt the last sip of Firewhisky burn his tongue on its way down, and he opened the drawer with borrowed courage. Dust rose into the air and made him cough, revealing yellowed parchment with black spiky letters that he had written twenty years ago.

(2010: fireworks, girls, laughter, Rosmerta serving free cocktails at the Three Broomsticks in honour of England's World Cup Victory, and a few miles away, the last breaths of one of the greatest wizards who had ever lived. A mad year, thrumming with all the wild excess that desperation brings)

Albus Dumbledore had been an alchemist before he had become a teacher.

Like the myths said: lead into gold.

(could he turn people into gold as well?)

But it was all a lie, Harry reminded himself. Lead could never turn into gold; it always retained the memory of being lead. The dull black remained beneath the glittering surface, "like Hermione, who could never be anything more than a Muggle turned witch-- she had proved that when she chose them" (they said).

And he?

Harry didn't know.

He set the glass down with a clink and lifted out the top parchment. A letter, unsent, almost unwritten. He had been so confused in those days after Dumbledore had died; the thoughts that he had sworn never to speak had come bubbling to his lips and fingers and poured out. He had shoved them in a drawer after that, once he had collected himself; it would do no good to remember such times. Words gave his thoughts a solidity that he found disturbing, like placing them within the confines of a sentence somehow made them real--

He should have burned Hermione's letter, and his response to it.

He couldn't bring himself to, somehow.

Hermione-

Every birthday, a letter from you finds itself on my desk. Six years, seven letters-- the extra one was the one you wrote me after Ron died. That was a month after your trial, of course.

You blamed me for his death. And maybe I did cause it. Or maybe, like the papers said, it wasn't my fault, it wasn't my choice. The Death Eaters stormed the Ministry building before we could even react. I couldn't have saved him. It was just meant to be that way. Or maybe I did get him killed (you're right, he was only a target because he was close to me)... I used to be so sure of things, and now-- I'm not even sure of that.

I don't feel anything about your letter. I think I should feel something-- anger, happiness, grief-- but I don't. All I feel is tired. People say that I should be angry, and that what you did betrayed all of us, but... You're angry, though. You're angry at everyone and everything, not just me. I don't know how you can say those things about the people who were your friends, who loved you. Seamus, Ginny, me, even Professor Dumbledore.

Why didn't you write to me after he died?

I had to reread the letter you sent me for my last birthday, and it was all about how everything great I had ever done was because of somebody else. You sounded a little like Trelawney halfway through, when you talked about how it was only luck that saved me from the thousands of deaths that had my name written on them. You called me 'history's trained poodle and fate's bitch' (you must have been angry, because you don't swear generally. Or do you? I can't remember very much from before the riots and the madness, when we could still look at each other).

I touched my scar the other day, and the ridge is less defined. It's fading, for some inexplicable reason. I think I'm scared. Or maybe relieved. Or maybe a bit of both.

"It must be fate, Harry, it can't be you," you said, absolving me of Ron's blood in the last line of text. Were you being sarcastic, Hermione? Did I kill him, or did destiny? Does it make a difference? (not to him, anyway, death does that to people)

And were you trying to be kind or cruel?

II.

The first time was the simplest to analyse.

His success had been ensured by the loyalty of his father, the sacrifice of his mother, and the overconfident mistake of an arrogant wizard. It had set the tone of the others.

The second time, his success had been ensured by the stupidity of a weak-minded professor, the skills of his friends, and Dumbledore's careful deposition of the Philosopher's stone in his pocket. He hadn't wanted it then--

( No one worthy of greatness should ever want it, the Gryffindor ghosts said, and so he agreed.

In Slytherin, they scoffed at such sentiment.

If he had been Sorted into Slytherin... )

The third time, his success had been ensured by a long-dead wizard's sword, the tears of a phoenix, and the hazy mistakes of a fifteen-year-old wizard.

In the fourth time, his success had been ensured by the ineptitude of Cornelius Fudge and a time-turner pressed into his hands by Dumbledore.

The fifth time, his success had been ensured by a wand that refused to do battle and the ghosts murdered by its brother.

(do families share responsibility?)

And so on.

Eleven chances to die.

And not a single one where he could look back and say Yes, I did it and not have fate stare back cruelly, silently contradicting him.

It had been dark before him, a time filled with grey, and they needed a hero so badly they had wished him into existence.

Are wishes real?

Just Harry

(evening)

There's an unceasing wind that blows through this night

And there's dust in my eyes, that blinds my sight

And silence that speaks so much louder that words,

Of promises broken

I.

(Men at some time are masters of their fates: The fault is not in our stars, but in ourselves, that we are underlings)

Harry reached into the fire and retrieved Hermione's letter, burning his fingers. He looked at it for a few moments. Forgotten. He laughed, shaking his head, desperation making his features ugly. He stared at the quill in his hand with filmy, bloodshot eyes.

"I'll never be forgotten, Hermione, you idiot," he whispered, his breath shooting sparks into the air. The faint sour smell of Ogden's Old Firewhisky. "You never understood, did you? My name will echo forever; I will be one with eternity, because here I am, the Wizarding hero, something out of nothing, rags to riches, Cinderella turned into Prince Charming, the Boy Who Lived, after all--"

Unless.

Every story has laws, he realised, and in this one the laws were simply different. In this story, he was a hero, he was Gryffindor--

To escape (the word itself sounded subversive in his mouth) all he had to do was--

Break the law.

It was so childishly simple, words forming as if he had known them all along.

Harry placed the quill to paper and wrote, the black ink spilling and blotting because of his haste.

Cowards die a thousand deaths, heroes only one-- and I have died a little each day.

(he is trying to explain.

He soon realises the futility of the task and tears up the paper.

He does not try again, and that itself is defiance.)

He placed the quill down and watched the ink dry intensely, his breath harsh and warm.

( He is as insubstantial as Tom Riddle's memory rising from the ashy pages of a diary.

"I defy," he says, and he can feel Riddle's tongue in his mouth saying the words, only Riddle is defying death, and he is defying life. "I am.")

He had made only one decision in his life, a knock-kneed, immature, ill-informed eleven-year-old decision to whisper 'not Slytherin,' and his life had been built around that one moment. Harry didn't know-- was good the choice not to be evil? Was making no choice equivalent to making one?

No more--

He reached into his robes for his wand, feeling it cool and slick against his fingers like in the courtroom, and he placed it against his temple (his hand shook, because they compared it to sleep, and Harry hated sleep because in dreams he was always alone) and muttered the words that culminated the act that he had been trying to complete ever since Albus died, whether he knew it or not.

That one cowardly act took more courage than anything he had ever done, because behind his hand, there was no fate or destiny or sense of righteousness, but just Harry, as he had protested to Hagrid too many years ago.

Just before it was 'prepare to evacuate soul,' he heard a crack like something breaking, and he hoped it was the façade, but it was just the hollow sound of his wand striking the floor.

And then he died.

The Boy Who Lived fell to the floor gracelessly, his body colliding with the carpet in an anticlimactic thud.

He died for no cause.

Leaving no morals, no neat reasons that justified or vilified or milked sympathy.

He died.

That is all that can be truthfully said.

*

EPILOGUE

(nothing in his life became him like leaving it)

*

And after?

Perhaps he succeeded, and the story retracted its claws and allowed him to be forgotten, like all things, a return to the primordial nothingness out of which we originated, and he once again saved the Wizarding world from a fate worse than death: fictionalisation.

Or

Orla Quirke's publication of Hermione's words sparked off a controversy about truth and words and stories and reality and free will, and Harry Potter's name echoed down the halls of eternity.

Or

There is no story, no words that slithered around inside him, and he was simply another ageing, egocentric ex-Quidditch star who killed himself on a drunken impulse.

Or

This is just fiction, empty words because they were created in an impossible universe where the quill truly is mightier than the sword.

And tomorrow, all these words will be nothing but a memory (or not even that)--

And life will go on.

Or

The story continues, a never-ending machine of words that transfigure life-- speaking, like this, in Epilogues and sequels, reaching death and conquering it, delivering immortality in a few phrases.

Or

Perhaps...

Perhaps...

*

Idols are not meant to be touched; their gilt comes off on our hands.


*

AN:

Since this is metafiction, my author's notes beginning with refs to other stories is strangely appropriate.

"In the middle of the hall..." is a quote from Bede's Ecclesiastical History, here at http://students.washington.edu/jjcrump/courses/hstam460/bede.sparrow.html , which I came across in Narcissa Malfoy's brilliant 1975. It seemed fitting for Hermione. Right after that, she quotes a line from Beckett's Waiting for Godot ("they give birth..."). The event of Harry being stabbed was taken from Beckett's life. He was stabbed (I believe) in Paris by a man who said he didn't know why he had done it when later interrogated by the police.

'Magic' (V) begins with a quote in brackets, taken from Faster, Mudblood! Kill, Kill! by the talented MissMoppet. It is used in her story within a very different context, but I was reading Chapter 7 while writing this story and it just clicked. To be clear- it is NOT my writing, it is the lovely writing of MissMoppet. Emails have been dispatched for special permission- but it's all quoted up properly.

If the reader would like a particularly wonderful story that also features words themselves as an element, I'd recommend Hecate's amazing Words Beguile Him at witchfics.org. I have no doubt it inspired me to an extent.

'Magic' (III) has quite overt references to The Wizard of Oz by F. Baum, and an adapted line from Shakespeare's Macbeth with 'a little water clears them of the crime'. Nightmares (I) has the line 'the cold hard glass...' which is also a reference of sorts to Jean Rhys' Wide Sargasso Sea. 'Dulce et decorum est...' is a Latin saying, but used in the context of Wilfred Owen's poem of the same name, which I'm sure most people are familiar with.

As for the dreams, I'm not particularly well-versed in psychology, so forgive any inconsistencies, but they are indeed meant to be symbolic.

"She to whom vengeance..." is a bowlderised version of the first line of Psalm 94. "Prepare to evacuate soul" is a quote from Chuck Palahniuk's Fight Club. The narrative and style were inspired by Oranges are Not the Only Fruit by Jeanette Winterson and the work of Kurt Vonnegut, Jr.

The song quoted at the beginning of each section is Sorrow by Pink Floyd. Quotes are smattered throughout from Counting Crows, The Doors, Jack off Jill, Moby and Shakespeare's Macbeth ('bubble, bubble...' and 'nothing in his life became him like leaving it') along with a few other references. 'Men are sometimes masters...' is from Julius Caesar. 'I will be free...' comes from his Taming of the Shrew. 'Myths which are believed in...' is from George Orwell. The line at the end-- 'Idols are not...' comes from Madame Bovary by Flaubert.